Does Caffeine Affect Dental Implant Stability? A Prospective Cohort Study

Statement of the Problem: Caffeine intake affects bone metabolism through inhibition of osteoblast proliferation. Purpose: This study aims to assess the effect of caffeine consumption on implant stability in the healing period of patients. Materials and Method: A prospective cohort study is designed to assess implant stability in the posterior of the maxilla. Patients were divided into two groups based on daily caffeine intake as group 1 with consumption of 400 mg/daily caffeine or more, and group 2 with consumption of 100 mg/daily caffeine or less. The implant stability was measured by resonance frequency analysis (RFA). The mean implant stability quotients (ISQs) were calculated. RFA measurements were made at 4, 6 and 8 weeks after implant placement. Results: A total of 102 patients were studied (51 in each group). The mean of ISQ was 43.49± 2.32 in the group 1 and 42.78±2.34 in the group 2 at four weeks after insertion. The mean of ISQ was 50.86±3.06 in group 1 and 51.37±2.44 in the group at six weeks after implant placement. At eight weeks after implant surgery, the mean of ISQ was 56.78±3.77 in the group 1 and 57.84±1.82 in the group 2. The mean of ISQ between the two groups at 4, 6 and 8 weeks after implant placement was not statistically different. (p= 0.13, p= 0.36 and p= 0.08 respectively) The repeated measure test indicated a similar increase in ISQ in various study times in the two studied groups (p=0.47, df=1, F=0.52). Conclusion: Acquired data suggest that caffeine intake may not have a negative effect on implant stability in the healing period at the posterior of the maxilla.


Introduction
Caffeine is a well-known substance, which is found in coffee, tea, energy drinks, chocolate, and so on. Up to 80% of people consume caffeine around the world [1].
It is believed that caffeine could inhibit osteoblast proliferation in vitro by the increase of cyclic adenine monophosphate (cAMP) and the inhibition of the intracellular phosphodiesterase [2]. In an animal study, the use of caffeine resulted in lower volume of bone, reduced bone mineral density and delayed bone repair [3].
It was reported that the consumption of caffeine has increased the orthodontic tooth movement [4]. Implant stability is defined as the absence of clinical mobility, which is crucial for osseointegration. Resonance frequency analysis (RFA) stability measurement applies a bending load, which is similar to the clinical load and indicates the stiffness of the implant-bone connection [15]. To the best of our knowledge, no study has been done to assess the effect of caffeine intake on the stability and healing of dental implants.
The purpose of this study is to address the following question: Do patients consuming caffeine have lower implant stability during the healing period? We hypothesized that caffeine affects the bone healing process and decreases implant stability. Therefore, the aim of this study was to compare implant stability in patients with and without caffeine consumption.

Materials and Method
The authors designed a prospective cohort study. The Patients were divided up into two groups as group 1, in which patients took 400 mg/daily or more of caffeine, and group 2, in which the participants took caffeine for 100 mg/ daily or less. The estimated amount of caffeine intake is shown in Table 1.

Implant Surgery
All implants were placed in healed bone at least 12 weeks after tooth removal. A crestal incision was made on the alveolar ridge with two short releasing with preserving gingival tissue in the proximal and distal aspects adjacent to neighbor teeth. Instrumentation was performed based on the company guidelines. A dental implant (SGS, Switzerland) with 4.5mm x 10mm size was placed at the first or second molar area in the posterior of the maxilla. A smart peg was connected to the fixture.

Implant stability measurements
Two examiners who were blinded to the groups evaluated the implant stability. The stability of the implants was measured by RFA. An Osstell device (Osstell, Gothenburg, Sweden) was used.  (Figure 1). The inter-examiner reliability for the examiners was found to be Ka-
The possible effect of caffeine on bone metabolism was evaluated in a series of animal and clinical studies [6][7][8].
It is believed that caffeine has a negative effect on bone metabolism [9]. In this study, we studied the effect of caffeine with a dose of 400 mg/daily on implant stability during the healing period.
The dose of caffeine was estimated according to patients' self-reports. Various beverages with caffeine content were consumed which were documented. ISQ measurements at 4, 6, 8 weeks after implant placement indicated no significant difference in the mean of ISQ in patients who consumed more than 400 mg/daily and less than 100 mg/daily. It was suggested that the dose of caffeine more than 400 mg is toxic for human kind and less than 100 mg does not have a clinical effect on bone [10]. It was suggested that more than 300 mg daily caffeine (approximately 514 g, or 18 oz, brewed coffee) increases bone loss in human [11]. It could be interpreted that the use of caffeine in the healing period of dental implants does not have a negative effect on implant stability. Generally, we expect a low stability in D4 bone at the posterior of the maxilla. Therefore, any detrimental effect of caffeine could be easily observed. In our review, we did not find any similar study, which evaluated the effect of caffeine on implant stability during the healing period.
Duarte et al. [12] studied the effect of caffeine on the early stage of bone healing and also bone density in rats. They concluded that a high daily caffeine intake may have a negative effect on the early stages of bone healing, but does not change bone density 56 days after administration [12]. A hypothesis for the possible role of caffeine in bone metabolism is its effect on calcium metabolism and the proliferation of osteoblast-like cells [12]. Caffeine raises urinary calcium excretion by a decrease renal re-absorption and calcium absorption, which leads to a negative calcium balance [3,[13][14]. There were many studies, which have reported the effect of caffeine on osteoblast function in vivo [11,13,19].
Tasuang et al. [13] studied the effect of caffeine on osteoblasts derived in newborn Wistar rats' calvaria.
They reported that caffeine had possible deleterious effect on the osteoblasts viability, which may increase the rate of osteoblasts apoptosis [13]. Rapuri et al. [11] reported that caffeine could stimulate 1,25(OH)2D3 In dental research, caffeine was studied in orthodontic tooth movements. The study showed that drinking coffee might accelerate tooth movement in orthodontic treatment [4] Shirazi et al. [19], studied caffeine intake in rats and orthodontic tooth movement. They demonstrated that caffeine intake resulted in decreased root resorption and consumption with concentrations of 2 g/L and 3 g/L inhibited orthodontic tooth movement due to its influence on osteoclast numbers [19]. Moreover, it was shown that caffeine caused a delay in bone healing in socket following tooth extraction in rats [19].
Concerning the limitation of the present study, the estimation of the amount of caffeine intake by patients was performed based on self-reports, which may not be very precise.

Conclusion
Our findings indicate that caffeine intake may not have a negative effect on implant stability in the healing period at the posterior of the maxilla.